The following books were listed on the Chippewa Valley Schools library Catalog at the time of observation.
Booklooks.org has developed a content based rating system that rangers from 0 “For Everyone” to 5 “Aberrant Content” More info on that rating system can be found on their website. Where available that rating is listed along with the book. While there is only one book that we are aware of rated 5 “Aberrant Content”, there are many rated 4 out of 5.
The changing meaning of “young adult”
Most scholarly and governmental sources put young adult between 18 and 26. Some newer definitions bring that down to somewhere in the teenage years. A skeptic might suggest that the changing definition is meant to put things that were previously recommended for adults into the hands of teens. At a minimum, no books listed as young adult belong in elementary schools and none of the books listed as adult (many of which are in middle school) belong in any school. But we don’t rest our ultimate judgment on the publisher’s ever-changing view of what’s appropriate for our kids.
* * * Work in progress * * *
UPDATE!So far all 6 books that have gone though the district’s super-secret committee process have been approved to stay. We refer to it as super-secret because they violate the Public Meetings Act by holding the committees in secret and they claimed not to have any record of committee members in response to a FOIA request plainly violating that act as well.
Put another way, they are willing to shed the sexual material that students are ignoring, but connivingly insistent on keeping the bits of sexual propaganda that are successfully indoctrinating our kids.
And other books appear to have been removed without any acknowledgment by the district.
Books for which the school has taken some action on will be noted with “UPDATE!” and expanding those titles will give you the details of the update.
Jump to: MIDDLE SCHOOLS, 9th GRADE CENTERS, HIGH SCHOOLS
ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS
ALL BECAUSE YOU MATTER by Tami CharlesBook contains: inflammatory racial commentary
Book contains: controversial social and racial commentary; non-sexual nudity; and inflammatory historical commentary.
Book contains: encourages activism in young children
Book contains: contains mild profanity; controversial racial commentary; controversial social commentary including police brutality and gun control activism; and mild violence.
Book contains: racism
Book contains: profanity; alcohol use and abuse; sexual activities; and alternate sexualities.
Book Review Link
Book contains: depictions of alternate gender ideologies; boy stripping down to his underwear; and putting on makeup.
UPDATE: Reviewed and deemed appropriate for elementary school by library resource reconsideration committee.
Book contains: references to switching genders
Book contains: book contains sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity; and alcohol use.
UPDATE: There is an adult version of this book and a non-adult version. It has a similar title and a similar cover. It is our understanding that the adult version being ordered for the elementary library was a mistake. It has been removed from elementary library.
Book contains: sexuality; and alternate gender ideologies.
MIDDLE SCHOOLS
A Child Called IT by Dave Pelzer Book labeled: Young Adult UPDATE!Book contains: sexual content; this book chronicles the unforgettable account of one of the most severe child abuse cases in California history. It is the story of Dave Pelzer, who was brutally beaten and starved by his emotionally unstable, alcoholic mother: a mother who played tortuous, unpredictable games–games that left him nearly dead. He had to learn how to play his mother’s games in order to survive because she no longer considered him a son, but a slave; and no longer a boy, but an “it.”
UPDATE: Reviewed and deemed appropriate for grades 6-12. Book housed in an advisory location (Media Center Office) at middle schools where it can be specifically requested for check-out. This seems to be an admission that it’s inappropriate but they refuse to get rid of it. And it seems they will still give it out to middle school students without parental knowledge.
Book on shelf grades 9-12.
Rated 2/5- Trigger Warning-animal cruelty.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from Seneca Middle School Still remains in Iroquois Middle School.
Book contains: inflammatory racial and social commentary; profanity; alcohol and drug use; and violence
Book contains: sexual activities and commentary. The book also provides detailed guide to lesbianism.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review at middle school level. Reconsideration Committee meeting
scheduled for high school level.
Book contains: controversial social and racial commentary; non-sexual nudity; and inflammatory historical commentary.
Book contains: contains mild profanity; controversial racial commentary; controversial social commentary including police brutality and gun control activism; and mild violence.
Book contains: racism
Dear Martin by Nic Stone Book labeled: Young Adult UPDATE!
Book contains: profanity; racism; controversial racial and social commentary; and alcohol use involving minor
UPDATE: Reviewed and deemed appropriate for grades 9-12 by library resource reconsideration committee.
Book contains: alternate gender ideologies and transitioning; sexuality; non-sexual nudity; and sexual activities
Book contains: inflammatory racial commentary; explicit violence; and derogatory terms.
Book contains: sexual nudity, sexual activities, and profanity.
Book contains: sexual nudity and sexual activities; moderate profanity use; alcohol use; and gender ideologies.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from middle school. Still available at High School. Even though the district claims 1 challenge will cause it to be reviewed at every level, it seems the game they are playing here is choosing not to review it for high school level because it was challenged by a parent of a middle school student. Neverminded that such a student will enter a 9th grade center at 14 years old. So the same parent would have to wait and then challenge it again?
Book contains: alternate gender ideologies; alternate sexualities; hate; and inexplicit sexual activities
Book contains: sexual activities; sexual assault; sexual nudity; profanity; alcohol and drug use by minors; inflammatory gender references; and controversial social commentary.
Book contains: The book is mainly about all the perceived genders, sexualities, and pronouns. Communism and socialism are spoken about positively in several instances as the main character loves Soviet Russia and socialism.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from middle school. Still available at High School. Even though the district claims 1 challenge will cause it to be reviewed at every level, it seems the game they are playing here is choosing not to review it for high school level because it was challenged by a parent of a middle school student. Neverminded that such a student will enter a 9th grade center at 14 years old. So the same parent would have to wait and then challenge it again?
Book contains: inexplicit sexual nudity; inflammatory racial commentary; references to racism; and profanity.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from Algonquin & Seneca middle schools. Still available at Wyandot Middle School. Still available at High School. Even though the district claims 1 challenge will cause it to be reviewed at every level, by weeding from schools where it was challenged they avoid actually reviewing it for appropriateness and keep it in 4 out of 6 schools.
Book contains: book contains sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity; and alcohol use.
UPDATE: Challenge requested February 2023. Removed (weeded) without a review from middle school. Still available at High School having never been reviewed for appropriateness in response to challenge by middles school parent.
Book contains: explicit sexual activities including sexual assault and battery; prostitution involving minors and adults; explicit violence; and mild profanity.
NOTE: This is also a mandatory 12th grade English read, which requires a waiver to be signed for content.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from middle school. Still available at high school (including in 9th grade center) having never been reviewed for appropriateness in response to challenge by middle school parent.
Book contains: Anti-parent; anti-police; social justice; indoctrination
Book contains: sensationalizes suicide; detailed sexual assault. The book attempts to normalize sexual battery and assault.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) from middle school. Still available at High School.
Book contains: sexual nudity; sexual activities; and profanity.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review.
9th Grade Centers
A Child Called IT by Dave Pelzer Book labeled: Young Adult UPDATE!Book contains: sexual content; this book chronicles the unforgettable account of one of the most severe child abuse cases in California history. It is the story of Dave Pelzer, who was brutally beaten and starved by his emotionally unstable, alcoholic mother: a mother who played tortuous, unpredictable games–games that left him nearly dead. He had to learn how to play his mother’s games in order to survive because she no longer considered him a son, but a slave; and no longer a boy, but an “it.”
UPDATE: Reviewed and deemed appropriate for grades 6-12. Book housed in an advisory location (Media Center Office) at middle schools where it can be specifically requested for check-out. This seems to be an admission that it’s inappropriate but they refuse to get rid of it. And it seems they will still give it out to middle school students without parental knowledge.
Book on shelf grades 9-12.
Book contains: sexual nudity and sexual activities including sexual assault; alternate gender ideologies; profanity and derogatory terms; alcohol and drug use; and inflammatory racial commentary.
UPDATE: Reviewed and Kept by CVS.
UPDATE 2: Appealed to Superintendent Roberts who also deemed this “Memoir-Manifesto” (that’s the subtitle of the book) both appropriate and valuable. He also called his own view objective in the appeal denial letter.
Book contains: sexual activities and commentary. The book also provides detailed guide to lesbianism.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review at middle school level. Reconsideration Committee meeting
scheduled for high school level.
Book contains: CONTENTS
Book contains: CONTENTS
Book contains: sexually explicit content; profanity; alcohol and drug use
Book contains: sexual activities; beastiality commentary; violence; profanity
Book contains: sexual activities between a minor and an adult; sexual nudity; and excessive/frequent profanity.
Book contains: explicit sexual activities; sexual battery; profanity; and drug abuse.
Book contains: profanity; racism; controversial racial and social commentary; and alcohol use involving minor
UPDATE: Reviewed and Kept by CVS.
Book contains: sexual activities; profanity; and racist commentary
Book contains: sexual nudity and sexual activities
Book contains: sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity; drug abuse and alcohol use.
Book contains: inexplicit sexual activities; profanity; suicidal ideation; and drug abuse
Book contains: inexplicit sexual activities including sexual assault and prostitution involving minor; drug abuse; alcohol use; profanity and derogatory terms; and suicidal commentary
Book contains: CONTENTS
Book contains: explicit sexual activities including sexual assault and child molestation; violence including self-harm and suicidal ideations; profanity and derogatory terms; and drug and alcohol abuse.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review.
Book contains: sexual activities; beastiality commentary; profanity and derogatory terms
Book contains: sexual activities; alternate sexualities; and profanity
Book contains: explicit violence including child abuse; explicit sexual activities including sexual assault and battery; and sexual nudity
Book contains: contains obscene excerpts involving sexual assault/battery; sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity; and drug use.
Book contains: sexual nudity and sexual activities
Book contains: illustrations depicting non-sexual nudity; sexual activities including sexual assault.
UPDATE: Reviewed and deemed appropriate for grades 10-12 by library resource reconsideration committee. Book housed in an advisory
location (Media Center Office) where it can be specifically requested for check-out. This seems to be an admission that it’s inappropriate but they refuse to get rid of it. And it seems they will still give it out without parental knowledge.
Book contains: violence; inflammatory racial commentary; controversial social commentary; sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity/derogatory terms; and alcohol use.
Book contains: sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity and derogatory terms; violence; controversial social and political commentary; controversial religious commentary; alternate sexualities; hate; abortion; and suicide commentary.
Book contains: contains violence including child abuse; references to sexual assault; profanity; inflammatory religious commentary; alternate gender ideologies; inflammatory commentary on government and society including policing.
Book contains: explicit violence including animal cruelty; inexplicit sexual activities including beastiality; sexual nudity; profanity; and inflammatory religious commentary.
Book contains: explicit aberrant sexual activities including rape of a minor; prostitution; and explicit violence.
Book contains: inexplicit sexual nudity; inflammatory racial commentary; references to racism; and profanity.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from Algonquin & Seneca middle schools. Still available at Wyandot Middle School. Still available at High School. Even though the district claims 1 challenge will cause it to be reviewed at every level, by weeding from schools where it was challenged they avoid actually reviewing it for appropriateness and keep it in 4 out of 6 schools.
Book contains: book contains sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity; and alcohol use.
UPDATE: Challenge requested February 2023. Removed (weeded) without a review from middle school. Still available at High School having never been reviewed for appropriateness in response to challenge by middles school parent.
Book contains: profanity and derogatory terms; sexual activities including sexual assault and molestation; alcohol use; inflammatory racial and religious commentary and references.
Book contains: inflammatory religious and racial commentary; violence including self harm; and profanity
Book contains: graphic pornography, masturbation, peer to peer physical abuse, child abuse/abandonment/neglect, solicitation of prostitutes, pedophilia, sexual assault, incest, victim shamming, extreme profanity, bigotry, alcohol and drug use – including drunk driving
Book contains: inflammatory racial commentary; frequent profanity; and inexplicit sexual activities.
Book contains: explicit sexual activities including sexual assault and battery; prostitution involving minors and adults; explicit violence; and mild profanity.
NOTE: This is also a mandatory 12th grade English read, which requires a waiver to be signed for content.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from middle school. Still available at high school (including in 9th grade center) having never been reviewed for appropriateness in response to challenge by middle school parent.
Article
Book contains: mild profanity; alternate sexualities; sexual activities including sexual assault; sexual nudity; violence; alcohol use; and suicide commentary.
Book contains: sexual activities including assault and battery; sexual nudity; profanity; violence; alcohol and drug use.
Book contains: sensationalizes suicide; detailed sexual assault. The book attempts to normalize sexual battery and assault.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) from middle school. Still available at High School.
Book Review Link
Book contains: explicit sexual activities including child rape and abuse; drug abuse; violence; alcohol use; and adult and child prostitution.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review.
HIGH SCHOOLS
A Child Called IT by Dave Pelzer Book labeled: Young Adult UPDATE! Book contains: sexual content; this book chronicles the unforgettable account of one of the most severe child abuse cases in California history. It is the story of Dave Pelzer, who was brutally beaten and starved by his emotionally unstable, alcoholic mother: a mother who played tortuous, unpredictable games–games that left him nearly dead. He had to learn how to play his mother’s games in order to survive because she no longer considered him a son, but a slave; and no longer a boy, but an “it.”
UPDATE: Reviewed and deemed appropriate for grades 6-12. Book housed in an advisory location (Media Center Office) at middle schools where it can be specifically requested for check-out. This seems to be an admission that it’s inappropriate but they refuse to get rid of it. And it seems they will still give it out to middle school students without parental knowledge.
Book on shelf grades 9-12.
Book contains: profanity; explicit sexual nudity; and obscene references to sexual activities.
Book contains: graphic violence; explicit sexual nudity; obscene sexual activities; profanity.
Book contains: sexual nudity; obscene explicit sexual activities; mild profanity; and violence.
Book image link
Book contains: sexually explicit alternate gender ideologies; alternate sexualities; and inexplicit sexual activities.
Book contains: alternate gender ideologies and alternate sexualities. This book educates young adults about the use of pronouns for alternate gender ideologies.
Book contains: inflammatory racial and social commentary; profanity; alcohol and drug use; and violence
Book contains: sexual nudity and sexual activities including sexual assault; alternate gender ideologies; profanity and derogatory terms; alcohol and drug use; and inflammatory racial commentary.
UPDATE: Reviewed and Kept by CVS.
UPDATE 2: Appealed to Superintendent Roberts who also deemed this “Memoir-Manifesto” (that’s the subtitle of the book) both appropriate and valuable. He also called his own view objective in the appeal denial letter.
Book contains: sexual activities and commentary. The book also provides detailed guide to lesbianism.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review at middle school level. Reconsideration Committee meeting
scheduled for high school level.
Book contains: CONTENTS
Book contains: explicit sexual activities including sexual assault; alcohol use; drug abuse; and profanity.
Book contains: Alcohol and drug use; profanity and derogatory terms; sexual activities; alternate sexualities.
Book contains: sexual activities; beastiality commentary; violence; profanity
Book contains: Inexplicit sexual activities; sexual nudity; excessive/frequent profanity derogatory terms; violence; controversial racial social commentary; controversial religious commentary; and alcohol and drug use by a minor.
Book contains: explicit sexual activities; profanity; alternate sexualities; violence including attempted sexual assault; molestation; alcohol use; drug abuse; and controversial religious commentary
Book contains: explicit sexual activities; sexual battery; profanity; and drug abuse.
Book contains: sexual activities; sexual nudity;
Book contains: profanity; racism; controversial racial and social commentary; and alcohol use involving minor
UPDATE: Reviewed and Kept by CVS.
Book contains: sexual activities; profanity; and racist commentary
Book contains: sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity; drug abuse and alcohol use.
Book contains: profanity; alcohol use and abuse; sexual activities; and alternate sexualities.
Book contains: sexual activities; sexual nudity; drug use; profanity; and alternate gender ideologies.
Book Review Link
Book contains: alternate sexualities; sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity and derogatory term; violence including self- harm; and controversial religious commentary.
Book contains: Sexual activities including rape; sexual nudity; sexuality; profanity; drug and alcohol abuse; inflammatory racial commentary; and gender ideologies.
Book contains: inexplicit sexual activities; profanity; suicidal ideation; and drug abuse
Book contains: inexplicit sexual activities including sexual assault and prostitution involving minor; drug abuse; alcohol use; profanity and derogatory terms; and suicidal commentary
Book contains: alcohol and drug use by minors; profanity; inexplicit sexual activities; and nudity.
Book contains: CONTENTS
Book contains: sexual activities; profanity; alcohol use; violence; suicide commentary; child molestation and sexual assault; controversial religious commentary; and alternate sexualities.
Book contains: explicit sexual activities including sexual assault and child molestation; violence including self-harm and suicidal ideations; profanity and derogatory terms; and drug and alcohol abuse.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review.
Images from the graphic novel
Book contains: profanity; controversial and inflammatory racial and cultural commentary; controversial religious commentary; sexual activities; sexual nudity; alternate gender ideologies; alternate sexualities; and drug use.
Book Link
Book contains: obscene sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity; drug and alcohol use; and violence including suicidal ideations.
Book contains: sexual activities; beastiality commentary; profanity and derogatory terms
Book contains: sexual activities; alternate sexualities; and profanity
Book contains: sexual activities; sexual nudity;
Book contains: explicit violence including child abuse; explicit sexual activities including sexual assault and battery; and sexual nudity
Book contains: sexual nudity and sexual activities; moderate profanity use; alcohol use; and gender ideologies.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from middle school. Still available at High School. Even though the district claims 1 challenge will cause it to be reviewed at every level, it seems the game they are playing here is choosing not to review it for high school level because it was challenged by a parent of a middle school student. Neverminded that such a student will enter a 9th grade center at 14 years old. So the same parent would have to wait and then challenge it again?
Book contains: contains obscene excerpts involving sexual assault/battery; sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity; and drug use.
Book Link
Book contains: obscene sexual activities; sexual nudity; alcohol use; and profanity.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review.
Book Review
Book contains: alcohol use; profanity; sexual activities; and sexual nudity
Book contains: sexual nudity and sexual activities
Book contains: illustrations depicting non-sexual nudity; sexual activities including sexual assault.
UPDATE: Reviewed and deemed appropriate for grades 10-12 by library resource reconsideration committee. Book housed in an advisory
location (Media Center Office) where it can be specifically requested for check-out. This seems to be an admission that it’s inappropriate, but the refuse to get rid of it. And it seems they will still give it out without parental knowledge.
Book contains: alternate sexualities; sexual activities; sexual nudity; excessive/frequent profanity; derogatory terms; alcohol and drug use; and self-harm including suicide
Book contains: sexual content (including sex with corpses); extreme violence (animals and humans, including cannibalism); homosexuality; alcohol use; drug use; mental health issues; bullying; suicide; child abuse/abandonment
Book contains: violence; inflammatory racial commentary; controversial social commentary; sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity/derogatory terms; and alcohol use.
Book contains: sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity and derogatory terms; violence; controversial social and political commentary; controversial religious commentary; alternate sexualities; hate; abortion; and suicide commentary.
Book Review
Book contains: sexual activities; profanity; suicide; and alcohol use.
Book contains: sexual activities including sexual assault; drug and alcohol abuse; profanity and derogatory terms; inflammatory racial commentary; self-harm including anorexia and suicide
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review.
Book contains: contains violence including child abuse; references to sexual assault; profanity; inflammatory religious commentary; alternate gender ideologies; inflammatory commentary on government and society including policing.
Book contains: alternate sexualities; alternate gender ideologies; and controversial racial and social commentary.
Book contains: sexual activities; sexual assault; sexual nudity; profanity; alcohol and drug use by minors; inflammatory gender references; and controversial social commentary.
Book contains: explicit violence including animal cruelty; inexplicit sexual activities including beastiality; sexual nudity; profanity; and inflammatory religious commentary.
Book contains: explicit aberrant sexual activities including rape of a minor; prostitution; and explicit violence.
Book contains: The book is mainly about all the perceived genders, sexualities, and pronouns. Communism and socialism are spoken about positively in several instances as the main character loves Soviet Russia and socialism.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from middle school. Still available at High School. Even though the district claims 1 challenge will cause it to be reviewed at every level, it seems the game they are playing here is choosing not to review it for high school level because it was challenged by a parent of a middle school student. Neverminded that such a student will enter a 9th grade center at 14 years old. So the same parent would have to wait and then challenge it again?
Book contains: inexplicit sexual nudity; inflammatory racial commentary; references to racism; and profanity.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from Algonquin & Seneca middle schools. Still available at Wyandot Middle School. Still available at High School. Even though the district claims 1 challenge will cause it to be reviewed at every level, by weeding from schools where it was challenged they avoid actually reviewing it for appropriateness and keep it in 4 out of 6 schools.
Book contains: references to sexuality; inexplicit sexual nudity; sexual activities; drug and alcohol use; alternate gender ideologies; inflammatory racial commentary; and references to racism.
Book contains: profanity and derogatory terms; sexual activities including sexual assault and molestation; alcohol use; inflammatory racial and religious commentary and references.
Book contains: Alcohol use involving minors; profanity; sexual activities; sexual assault involving minors; and sexual nudity.
Book contains: excessive/frequent profanity; sexual activities; violence; sexual nudity; underage alcohol use; drug use; and sexual assault
Book contains: inflammatory racial commentary; frequent profanity; and inexplicit sexual activities.
Book contains: obscene sexual activities; sexual commentary; and excessive/frequent profanity.
Book contains: explicit sexual activities; alternate sexualities; violence; profanity; alcohol and drug use.
Book contains: explicit sexual activities including sexual assault and battery; prostitution involving minors and adults; explicit violence; and mild profanity.
NOTE: This is also a mandatory 12th grade English read, which requires a waiver to be signed for content.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review from middle school. Still available at high school (including in 9th grade center) having never been reviewed for appropriateness in response to challenge by middle school parent.
Article
Book contains: mild profanity; alternate sexualities; sexual activities including sexual assault; sexual nudity; violence; alcohol use; and suicide commentary.
Book contains: sexual activities including assault and battery; sexual nudity; profanity; violence; alcohol and drug use.
Book contains: contains inexplicit sexual nudity; sexual activities; references to sexuality; alcohol use; and frequent/excessive profanity.
Book contains: sensationalizes suicide; detailed sexual assault. The book attempts to normalize sexual battery and assault.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) from middle school. Still available at High School.
Book contains: controversial social, historical and racial commentary; hate including racism; and alternate sexualities.
Book contains: excerpts and illustrations depicting explicit nudity and sexual activities.
Book contains: explicit sexual activities including sexual assault; alcohol use; drug abuse; and profanity.
Book Review Link
Book contains: explicit sexual activities including child rape and abuse; drug abuse; violence; alcohol use; and adult and child prostitution.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review.
Book contains: inexplicit sexual activities and sexual nudity; alternate sexualities; inexplicit violence involving self-harm; and profanity.
Book contains: sexual nudity; sexual activities; and profanity.
UPDATE: Removed (weeded) without a review.
Book contains: influences teenagers to kneel for the National Anthem; encourages drug use and concealing from parents; states “well-behaved women rarely make history.”; racial privilege.
Book contains: self-harm including anorexia, bulimia, cutting and suicidal ideations; alcohol use; drug use; and profanity and derogatory terms.
Book contains: sexual activities; sexual nudity; profanity; self-harm including attempted suicide; alcohol use; controversial religious commentary; and alternate sexualities.